Most business owners I talk to genuinely believe they understand their SEO problem. They’re usually wrong about which problem it actually is – but they’re right that there’s a gap. There almost always is.
After auditing hundreds of websites, I keep seeing the same three gaps come up over and over. And if you can close them, you’ll outrank most of your competitors without any tricks.
1. Your Content Is Too Thin – And Too Vague
This is the most common issue I find, by a long way.
Businesses write a paragraph about a service and call it done. But Google is trying to understand whether your page is the best answer to someone’s question – and a paragraph doesn’t cut it. If a potential client is searching for, say, “commercial kitchen fit-out Brisbane,” they want a page that genuinely explains what the process involves, what to expect, how long it takes, and what questions they should be asking. Not three dot points and a contact form.
Two things I see constantly:
- No dedicated pages for specific services. If you offer five services, you need five pages. Cramming everything onto one “Services” page splits your relevance and dilutes everything. Google would rather serve people a specific page, rather than a general page.
- Thin content that doesn’t demonstrate expertise. Google’s EEAT framework (Experience, Expertise, Authority, Trust) rewards businesses that show their knowledge – not just claim it. If you’ve been doing this for 20 years, that needs to come through in your content. Write like the expert you are.
Ask yourself: if someone landed on your service page with zero knowledge of your industry, would they leave feeling genuinely informed? If not, the content needs work.
2. Your Online Authority Is Lacking
Thin content has a downstream effect – it means other websites don’t link to you, cite you, or reference you. And without that, Google has no reason to favour your site over a competitor’s.
Authority is built when other credible websites in your industry or local area link back to you. Industry directories, local business citations, supplier websites, PR mentions, trade publications – these all send signals that your business is legitimate and worth ranking.
Most businesses I audit have almost none of this. And the ones that do have links often have the wrong kind – generic directories from 2011 that provide no real value, or spammy paid links from unrelated websites.
3. You Don’t Know Who Your Real Competitor Is
Here’s one that surprises almost every client I work with: the business you consider your main competitor is almost never your actual online competitor.
Your “perceived competitor” is the business you go up against for clients. Your Google competitor is whoever is ranking on page one for the terms your customers are actually searching. These are often completely different businesses – sometimes smaller operators, sometimes national brands, sometimes aggregator websites.
This matters because if you’re trying to benchmark your SEO performance against the wrong business, your whole gap analysis is off. The first step of a proper SEO audit is identifying who is actually winning the search results in your space.
How to Close the Gap
The process is straightforward, even if the work isn’t always quick:
- Find out who is actually ranking for your target terms online
- Audit what they’re doing across content, authority, and trust signals
- Identify where your gaps are
- Close them – systematically
That’s genuinely it. SEO doesn’t have to be complicated. But it does have to be done properly, and it has to start with an honest look at where you actually stand.
If you want help with that, an audit is a good place to start.
Leave a Reply